Needless to say, it was not a good night for Dr. Sybrowsky.
However, today this annoying trait paid off. He ducked out of a surgery this morning and ran (literally) down Pill Hill to the court to argue his case in front of the judge. Here are his points and statement if you care to play judge yourself:
I do not contest the fact that I was at least partially parked in the disabled parking spot. Although I can not substantiate precisely where my car was parked in relation the contested parking spot, I have faith that there was no malice on the part of the parking officials. However, I feel somewhat deceived by the vague and inappreciable demarcation of the spot in question. The state code stipulates only that the designated spot be marked with a standard blue “disabled” sign, but makes no recommendation regarding the visibility of the sign or the proximity of the sign to the spot in question. Although, in a strict sense, the parking spot in question meets the standard stipulated by the statute, it is reasonable to assume that such a designation, along with its substantial fine, would be accompanied by a reasonable effort to make the designation conspicuous. I have demonstrated that the current situation is unclear at best. I have also demonstrated that I had no reason to park my vehicle in violation of any parking code, short of being unclear or unaware of the violation. I am therefore petitioning the court to reduce my fine.
Unclearly marked
- Sign perpendicular to parking spot
- Set back~8’ from the road
- White line on top of curb on passenger side
- Mid-way down a row of 10 regular parking spots
- No demarcation for cars coming the opposite way
- Sign was placed on the phone pole for convenience, with no attempt made to demarcate the designated spot in a conspicuous manner
- Unclear where in relation to the sign I was parked
o Demarcation with ambiguous and inconspicuous “white line”
o How much I overlapped not known
o Sign not visible with >75% of car in the spot
- Employee of Harborview medical center with hundreds of parking spots available to me
- No paucity of spots on the night in question
- Current personal financial situation makes me vigilant about avoiding fines, etc. I would not have parked in the spot had I known it was designated a disabled parking spot.
Financial burden
- $250 + nearly $200 in towing costs is unduly burdensome
If you're anything like the judge, you are impressed. And she was. Perhaps she agreed. Or perhaps she just doesn't see many traffic violators this articulate and well-prepared and was pleasantly surprised. Either way, she did something we did not expect. She dismissed the fine altogether. Wa-hoo! We were hoping for a reduction in the least, but not a dismissal. She couldn't waive the towing fee we paid, but we're so glad not to pay for a $250 ticket we don't care.
So my incredibly intelligent, articulate, and attractive husband, although your infatuation with debate will always be exasperating to me, you do ROCK! Maybe someday when you're retired you can go to law school, just for the fun of it. (I think all the Sybrowkys would agree that only Cree would think of law school as "fun." Kind of like that time he got up in the middle of the night to write an essay on nature "just for fun. . .")




8 comments:
Good job-very compelling argument. No wonder the judge ruled in your favor. Our car got towed in Chicago-and it was the same thing, poor signage and street markings. Unfortunately, in order to argue our 'case', we would have had to fly back to Chicago a few months later. Whatever.
I don't know what to say... I'm still laughing!!! Way to go Christian!! I actually wish Nate had some more of that argument side to him. Please have Christian rub that off on my cute husband b/c he would look at it as... I don't have time & why bother b/c they will still give me the ticket! {Don't you worry.. it never fails, he gets a ticket just looking at him} :)
Seriously, that was a well THOUGHT out post!!
Love it~
The judge should have doubled the fine just to humble him. In reality, the goofy doctors think they can do whatever they want within the vicinity of a hospital. I'd vote for a few days in jail ... except Christian would enjoy the break in his schedule too much.
jls
Mandi-
It's so good to hear from you. First off way to go to your hubby. I did speech and debate it college so I can see myself doing the same thing. From the pictures he definitly shouldn't be getting a ticket.
Jennelee told me you came in. Crazy that is the only remaining SAM huh. We are best friend now so I keep up on all the latest at SU between her and Natalie. Things have really changed in the past 2 years. I think I would probably still be around if Natalie was still our manager. I adored her! Now it's just another department with very little personality or relationships that Natalie built. I miss it some days but I love being home with Alex. Your little boys are soooo cute. How is living in Seattle? p.s. of course you can add me to your list.
Wow! I thought you were the writer. Well, if I ever need something to argue, I know where to come. Clark can argue but not so eloquently
holy crap. i need a dictionary and thesaurus to read this (or spell thesaurus?!)
well argued, cree. well argued.
well written, randa. well written!
You know, that was an alarming revelation somehow. Remember how I was accepted to law school, then didn't go, because I couldn't stomach the idea of spending day sin the library? Well, I took a personality test a few weeks ago that said I should've been a lawyer. And the way you described Christi's behavior...sounds a lot like me. I make Jesse debate stuff with me all the time. I've finally gotten him to not just give in to keep the peace - I don't want to just be right, I want him to fight me on it! I have this eerie feeling that I should've sucked it up and gone to law school... In any case, that was an awesome story.
Ahhh... it all comes back to the nature essay. Fond memories... how apropos
Post a Comment